Gaming AI-Assisted Peer Reviews Poses New Risks to the Scientific Community
By Lin Li, Qi Zhang, Xander Davies, Jianing Qiu, Yarin Gal
This paper shows that AI-assisted peer review systems can be manipulated through superficial rephrasing of manuscript abstracts, improving review outcomes without changing scientific content. The vulnerability holds across disciplines and even without knowledge of the reviewing model, raising concerns about the integrity of AI-mediated scientific evaluation.